Marquis de Soth wrote:Personally, I am very reluctant to impose and enforce a rule that can be so...subjective.
This, really. I dunno, the main problem with what Blood Lord wants to do is that it is very much a subjective thing to people whether an image is "good" or bad"---or, like in the cases above, "so bad it's funny" or "so bad it's not even funny at all." And, if we were to declare to people that we want "good" art here in the thread, it'll make people even more reluctant to post stuff, for fear of "what if what I think is good is bad to someone else?"
To me, this could potentially discourage people from posting at all in fear of being criticized. And, I dunno, I don't think that's really fitting in a thread that should make people feel...at home, perhaps? It's MLP, after all.
At the very least, we could simply encourage
people to look for and share what they consider good or fantastic pieces of art, alongside the funny, but not outright make it a rule that they could potentially get "punished" for if they don't follow it.